ObliviOS Developer portal Project site

Home / Decisions / ADR-112

Defer the independent-reproducibility requirement.

Accepted, recorded 28 September 2026.

Decision
ADR-112
Date
2026-09-28
Status
AcceptedAccepted
Mentions
ADR-025
Mentioned by
ADR-110, ADR-258

1Decision

Defer the independent-reproducibility requirement (supply-chain Stage 5, retained "in full" by the Personal Stable design) for stallion's Personal Stable candidates until the build host has the capacity for an independent rebuild.

2Why and evidence

An independent rebuild needs a second source tree plus a full output directory. The build host's /srv had 52G free on 2026-09-28, with out-lynx and out-stallion at 125G each, and no second tree exists. Owner decision 2026-09-28: reproducibility comes later and is not a priority now. Recorded as an explicit deferral instead of a silent skip, so the gap stays visible.

3Consequences

Until an independent rebuild matches byte-for-byte, every stallion ceremony record and docs/devices/support-policy.md entry marks the device's Personal Stable status as "reproducibility pending". What is lost meanwhile is detection of a compromised build host, or of a dirty source tree, between committed source and signed artifact (ADR-025's uncommitted frameworks/base edits are exactly the case a rebuild catches).

Mitigations kept: every build starts from committed branches with a clean git status in every touched project; candidate hashes are computed independently on the build host and on the signing host. Separately, vendor/.../guardian is not in the repo manifest, so an independent rebuild could not reproduce it today; that must be fixed before the first rebuild attempt.

4Review when

Build-host disk expanded; any sign of build-host compromise; before this device's build integrity is ever claimed to anyone other than the owner.

Read from docs/governance/decision-log.md, entry ADR-112.