- Decision
- ADR-110
- Date
- 2026-09-28
- Status
- AcceptedAccepted
- Mentions
- ADR-028, ADR-106, ADR-111, ADR-112
- Mentioned by
- ADR-111
1Decision
Adopt the Personal Stable channel exactly as specified in docs/superpowers/specs/2026-09-27-personal-stable-trust-tier-design.md: a single-owner, single-device production-trust tier that keeps Stable's technical controls (release key material only in the signing host's encrypted vault, a logged ceremony, independent reproducibility, bootloader relock with rollback enforcement verified by a clean post-relock boot) and drops only Stable's multi-custodian and separation-of-duties requirements.
2Why and evidence
The owner approved the design on 2026-09-27. Its own adoption path makes a decision-log entry the step that turns it into a binding decision; the ADR number it anticipated (ADR-106) was taken by the AirPods design, so this is that entry. No existing channel covers one owner who wants a relocked, release-signed phone for their own daily use: Alpha provides no production trust, and Stable requires a second custodian who does not exist.
The dropped controls stop one malicious operator from shipping trojaned code to other people's devices; with exactly one device, owned and operated by that same person, they add no protection. ADR-028 used the same reasoning for single-operator Alpha.
3Consequences
docs/release/supply-chain-and-signing.md gains a Personal Stable row. The design's scoping guardrails bind every Personal Stable build: one named device, serial kept only in protected operations records, the single owner as sole custodian, a key distinct from any future public Stable key. Public Stable is unchanged and Personal Stable evidence never carries over to it. ADR-111 and ADR-112 apply the tier to stallion with recorded deviations.
4Review when
A second device, a second person, or any public distribution of a Personal Stable build (must go through real Stable instead); any proposed change to the design's guardrails.
Read from docs/governance/decision-log.md, entry ADR-110.