ObliviOS Developer portal Project site

Home / Decisions / ADR-250

Reject the first mockups of the two sites and reopen the visual direction of section 5.5 of the public launch design.

Accepted, recorded 17 November 2026.

Decision
ADR-250
Date
2026-11-17
Status
AcceptedAccepted (owner, 2026-11-17: the result is anything but good, not an authentic site but a standard, ugly, unremarkable one, \"AI slop\"; the owner wants it truly beautiful). Done: the four pages were built as static HTML with a shared stylesheet and checked at 1440 and 390 px wide in both schemes (a scratchpad build, not kept); the Impeccable direction round was started (seed reference seed:77b93c1015493d72, assigned grounded index 3, six challengers dealt) and not answered; the owner then invoked the skill emil-design-eng with the words \"use this one, it is better\" and closed the session, so which skill or direction the owner chose is not recorded and is asked at the start of the next design session. The launcher of the Impeccable skill has no execute bit and runs as sh <launcher> <verb>. Not done: a chosen direction, new mockups, W-1, the claim review of the draft copy (C-1).
Mentions
ADR-208
Mentioned by
ADR-251, ADR-268

1Decision

Reject the first mockups of the two sites and reopen the visual direction of section 5.5 of the public launch design (restrained and technical, warm grey and brick red as the only accent, Roboto Flex). The mockups of 2026-11-17 (oblivios.org home and Verify it, oblivios.dev decision log and the page of ADR-208, each in light and dark, on desktop and on a phone) are not accepted and gate W-1 stays open. The sites are designed again: a direction round first, rendered images of the chosen direction shown to the owner, and no site code before the owner approves them.

2Why and evidence

The first build followed the brief literally (a quiet ledger layout, hairlines, one accent, a register of areas instead of cards) and read as a documentation template, which the design names as an anti-goal (section 2: \"professional\" turning out to mean a template). The owner's measure is a site that is distinctive and beautiful, not one that is merely clean. Rejected: polishing the same layout (the layout and world were the problem, not the finish), keeping the pinned look and changing only colours or type.

3Consequences

The drafted text (the hero sentence, seven area descriptions with their ADR links, the verification steps, the stage line, the ADR-208 page) was taken from the READMEs and ADRs and is reusable, but it is unreviewed. A new look must keep the privacy rules of section 5.4 (no request to another host, no cookie, no local storage, light and dark, WCAG 2.2 AA, attribution and non-affiliation on every page). A new direction roll gives a new seed; the seed of this entry is not reused.

4Review when

The owner names a skill or direction; mockups of the chosen direction are shown; the owner approves or rejects them (W-1).

Read from docs/governance/decision-log.md, entry ADR-250.