ObliviOS Developer portal Project site

Home / Decisions / ADR-207

Amend point 3 of ADR-191: the offer that a typed or deleted character ends for a field comes back when that field is empty again, and still comes back when the next…

Proposed, recorded 30 October 2026.

Decision
ADR-207
Date
2026-10-30
Status
ProposedProposed (owner 2026-10-30; written, not built)
Part
Keyboard
Mentions
ADR-191

1Decision

Amend point 3 of ADR-191: the offer that a typed or deleted character ends for a field comes back when that field is empty again, and still comes back when the next field gets focus or the keyboard is shown again. While the field holds any text the chips stay away. The null filter and the exact chip sizes of ADR-191 are unchanged.

2Why and evidence

The owner, on lynx 2026103001 during ACH-005: after clearing a filled user name in the focused field no chip came back, and the owner expects one [measured: the chip stayed away until the page was reloaded].

The replaced rule comes from plan decision D4 and aims at a keyboard that cannot probe the stored value by typing; an empty field holds no typed text to compare with, and the null filter already keeps the system from matching typed text [assumption: the chips returning at an empty field tell the keyboard nothing that the offer at focus did not].

The platform sends the chips again when the field empties [verified-in-source: Session.updateViewStateAndUiOnValueChangedLocked calls filterInlineFillUiLocked, which sends the response to the keyboard, and InlineFillUi.includeDataset returns every dataset for an empty filter text]; that Vanadium reports the value change of its web field to the session was not measured.

3Consequences

A keyboard that deletes a field empty sees the chips return; ACH-007 reads with the new expectation and ACH-014 and ACH-016 must still pass. The policy of the keyboard changes by patch 0002 of keyboard/autofill-chips (AutofillChipPolicy.onFieldEmpty, the controller asks the editor after typing only); it is host-checked and type-checked and landed on the build server (8a5787c9f, 2026-10-30), not module-built and in no image.

4Review when

ACH-007 shows the chips not returning at an empty field, or ACH-014 or ACH-016 shows that returning chips leak the stored value.

Read from docs/governance/decision-log.md, entry ADR-207.