- Decision
- ADR-161
- Date
- 2026-10-13
- Status
- AcceptedAccepted (owner, 2026-10-13) for (1) to (6); the measurement rows
MAP-032andMAP-033and the size of the city part are open; the code is on branchdatamap-ipmapofsovereignos-platformand not landed (ADR-164 corrects and replaces parts of it); an image needs a code review and the owner's request first - Part
- Atlas
- Mentions
- ADR-157, ADR-164
- Mentioned by
- ADR-164
1Decision
The Live Data Map gains server places, as set out in 2026-10-13-server-places-design.md. (1) Every contacted address gets a hosting country and a network operator from server-country and origin-asn of sapics/ip-location-db (PDDL-1.0), pinned by SHA-256 and shipped as one read-only file in the system image. (2) The lookup runs in the collector at the event; only country and ASN are kept, never the address.
(3) The interface says "hosted in" and names the operator, never the company's country; an anycast address (the UT-DACS/Anycast-Census prefixes, MPL-2.0) and a network that steers by DNS (a short list: Amazon, Akamai, Microsoft) get no place. (4) City level comes from DB-IP Lite (CC BY 4.0, attribution in Atlas); a server place is drawn where the data puts the address, otherwise at the capital of the country.
(5) The user chooses whether the opt-in history keeps server places (off by default). (6) Geofeeds with no explicit licence are accepted as part of the PDDL data. (7) This supersedes the part of ADR-157 (3) that says no address is looked up, no GeoIP database is used and every place on the map is a company or publisher base: a server place is a second kind of place, drawn apart and worded as "hosted in".
The row "Where an address is" of the design of 2026-10-11 and the capability row of the collector, which listed address-to-place lookups as not done, are corrected with this entry. The company bases of ADR-157 stay.
2Why and evidence
69% of the classifier's domains have no company with a place, and open company data cannot close that: Wikidata holds an item for 169 of 1988 such companies. An address always has a range, and 99.6% of the names that resolved got a country and an operator (research record).
3Consequences
A patch to the collector and the snapshot parcelable (privileged path, IPC surface); about 8 MB more in the system image for IPv4 without the city part, which is larger; the interface must not claim more than the data says; a data file whose geofeed part has no explicit licence.
4Review when
The measured memory and cost of a lookup (MAP-032); the accuracy of the city part (MAP-033)
Read from docs/governance/decision-log.md, entry ADR-161.